Home > Forum > Complaining About Rates

Complaining about rates

Aug 23, 2023 at 08:20 AM CST
+ 19 - 7
I see all these posts about rates need to be over 4.00 per mile. Yet looking at power only boards here they are all day. But folks won't drop the end dumps and hoppers for a van. Y'all really need to expand your horizons.
Replied on Wed, Aug 23, 2023 at 08:44 AM CST
+ 1

Dad did run dry vans for awhile. At a time when rates were higher than that, and the issue is how far to get a reload and time spent unloading & loading. Those one-way rates are fine & dandy, but when you have to bounce 400 miles to get yourself in a position for reload that will take you to the great paying work that you are contracted for; then it becomes a whole lot less appealing. Those dry vans would not have swarmed the ag market, if those prices paid the bills. The arguing amongst ourselves gets old. Divided we fall, and lose hold of our industry; which we are seeing happen right now before our eyes.

Replied on Wed, Aug 23, 2023 at 08:44 AM CST
+ 1

And I now see that it was power only, but I would assume the same concept applies without the load & unload times. I don't understand why it is always the truck that is expected to "adapt" to another industry to pay the bills. They paid for the truck & trailer & any smart entrepaneur did it with work already lined out; but now that work is being traded in for trucks that don't care about the customer, or their product, for cheaper rates.

Replied on Thu, Aug 24, 2023 at 12:54 PM CST

Vans do pay much better.

But I can't do them. Got no freaking idea how to backup in a 90 . Couldn't back that thing in a dock or a parking spot.

That and I don't like blowing all over the road. I don't know how you guys can drive with a trailer going all over and tires up in air on one side

I never blew over but I'm sure I don't like it.

Replied on Thu, Aug 24, 2023 at 04:04 PM CST

As a broker who works with Vans, Reefers, and Bulk Equipment the markets are drastically different. As a specialized driver you put up with a lot for the rates you are paid. The market you work in is commodity based and that is the issue. Vans, Reefers, Flatbeds, and other trucks are able to base their market on several factors. As a bulk carrier, you are at the mercy of how the commodity sells.

Replied on Fri, Aug 25, 2023 at 10:01 AM CST
Quote: "As a broker who works with Vans, Reefers, and Bulk Equipment the markets are drastically different. As a specialized driver you put up with a lot for the rates you are paid. The market you work in is commodity based and that is the issue. Vans, Reefers, Flatbeds, and other trucks are able to base their market on several factors. As a bulk carrier, you are at the mercy of how the commodity sells. "

I disagree. I have known things to move only because freight was cheap. And I have hauled useless stuff and made good money but the trader lost money. But it had to move.

Replied on Fri, Aug 25, 2023 at 10:17 AM CST
- 1

If vans pay that well then why are you on Bulk Loads? Why aren't you running a dry van? According to TCI Business Capital the national average (loaded) dry van rate for August 2023 was $2.07 a mile, reefer is at $2.43 a mile, and flat bed rates are at $2.50 a mile. For me personally I try to keep my belt running for $2.50 ALL MILES and no I don't run local home every night runs very often.

The key to making money in bulk is getting away from the poverty wagon known as the hopper bottom, UNLESS YOU ARE A FARMER with lots of stored grain to move. Hoppers simply aren't versatile enough to be loaded both ways and the freight isn't valuable enough to make good money.

Replied on Fri, Aug 25, 2023 at 10:48 AM CST
+ 1
Quote: "If vans pay that well then why are you on Bulk Loads? Why aren't you running a dry van? According to TCI Business Capital the national average (loaded) dry van rate for August 2023 was $2.07 a mile, reefer is at $2.43 a mile, and flat bed rates are at $2.50 a mile. For me personally I try to keep my belt running for $2.50 ALL MILES and no I don't run local home every night runs very often. The key to making money in bulk is getting away from the poverty wagon known as the hopper bottom, UNLESS YOU ARE A FARMER with lots of stored grain to move. Hoppers simply aren't versatile enough to be loaded both ways and the freight isn't valuable enough to make good money. "

Not sure where you came up with this wisdom? We run 20 hoppers year round and make a good living with them! We are loaded 90%of our miles and do well as an average. This summer has been an abnormally slow summer with more bounce than normal, BUT we have done this to take care of our direct customers and we have still made enogh to stay profitable. The key to running hoppers is to only use this site as an absolute last ditch option for a load. If you have customers and a select group of brokers, most of which do not post loads on here unless they are in a bind, you can do well!

Replied on Fri, Aug 25, 2023 at 02:32 PM CST
- 1
Quote: "Not sure where you came up with this wisdom? We run 20 hoppers year round and make a good living with them! We are loaded 90%of our miles and do well as an average. This summer has been an abnormally slow summer with more bounce than normal, BUT we have done this to take care of our direct customers and we have still made enogh to stay profitable. The key to running hoppers is to only use this site as an absolute last ditch option for a load. If you have customers and a select group of brokers, most of which do not post loads on here unless they are in a bind, you can do well!"

Ed, I used to own a poverty wagon for a short time when I farmed more. I tried running that hopper for hire long enough to know the numbers weren't good enough.

Does your hoppers run commodities or in the oil fields? Being totally honest on your own numbers per truck, could you make a good living running a hopper as an owner operator?

Most hopper guys I talk to are running loaded 50-60% of their miles.

Replied on Sat, Aug 26, 2023 at 11:41 AM CST

What happens after you deliver power only? Better divide your $4 by 2 to get back.

Replied on Sun, Aug 27, 2023 at 06:32 AM CST
+ 1
Quote: "Not sure where you came up with this wisdom? We run 20 hoppers year round and make a good living with them! We are loaded 90%of our miles and do well as an average. This summer has been an abnormally slow summer with more bounce than normal, BUT we have done this to take care of our direct customers and we have still made enogh to stay profitable. The key to running hoppers is to only use this site as an absolute last ditch option for a load. If you have customers and a select group of brokers, most of which do not post loads on here unless they are in a bind, you can do well!"

6.50 loaded mile or it sits. Fuel is 4.29 in nd.

gravel guys get 165 hr.

lot of equipment is owned by finance companies. They are the ones bringing the rates downwards

Replied on Mon, Aug 28, 2023 at 06:50 AM CST

I would like to know what load board thoses loads are posted on ?? None of the boards that I have show numbers like that.

Replied on Mon, Aug 28, 2023 at 06:51 AM CST
Someone screenshot this same post off Facebook that you put up. Not sure what load board this is but the load board I’m on there is no such thing. Most of the power only is around 1.50 to 2.25
Replied on Mon, Aug 28, 2023 at 12:01 PM CST

What board are those on. I haven't found a hopper yet.

Replied on Mon, Aug 28, 2023 at 12:02 PM CST
+ 1
Quote: "Ed, I used to own a poverty wagon for a short time when I farmed more. I tried running that hopper for hire long enough to know the numbers weren't good enough. Does your hoppers run commodities or in the oil fields? Being totally honest on your own numbers per truck, could you make a good living running a hopper as an owner operator? Most hopper guys I talk to are running loaded 50-60% of their miles. "

We run the road. We stay loyal to our customers and our customers stay loyal to us. When a load is booked, it is delivered, unless there are cercumstances. The trick to making money with any trailer is to not jump around and chase the money! I know guys who hooked their wagon to the oil field and then when the oil field went south, they could not make it in the market and then proceeded to drive rates down. The same happened with the covid era. Everyone beating their chest when the rates were good and dumping hoppers to pull refers and dry vans to chase that big money and hopper guys screaming that they should make the same with the hopper! We cut a fat calf for 2 years and now, those who jumped around are now jumping back into the hopper sector and driving rates down again. The thing is, the guys who just stayed with hopper are not seeing the decrease in the rates, because we stuck with it. I have said it before and will say it again, what works for our company may not work for someone else, so you need to find your own niche and stick with it! Consistency is what make you money.

Replied on Mon, Aug 28, 2023 at 01:07 PM CST
Quote: "We run the road. We stay loyal to our customers and our customers stay loyal to us. When a load is booked, it is delivered, unless there are cercumstances. The trick to making money with any trailer is to not jump around and chase the money! I know guys who hooked their wagon to the oil field and then when the oil field went south, they could not make it in the market and then proceeded to drive rates down. The same happened with the covid era. Everyone beating their chest when the rates were good and dumping hoppers to pull refers and dry vans to chase that big money and hopper guys screaming that they should make the same with the hopper! We cut a fat calf for 2 years and now, those who jumped around are now jumping back into the hopper sector and driving rates down again. The thing is, the guys who just stayed with hopper are not seeing the decrease in the rates, because we stuck with it. I have said it before and will say it again, what works for our company may not work for someone else, so you need to find your own niche and stick with it! Consistency is what make you money."

You did not answer my question. If you used your own numbers would you make a good living as an O/O running a hopper? By a good living I mean $100,000 a year take home, because most full-time truck drivers can make that kind of money without the headache of owning a truck. If you run 20 hoppers you are making money on volume.

Replied on Mon, Aug 28, 2023 at 01:33 PM CST
+ 1
Quote: "You did not answer my question. If you used your own numbers would you make a good living as an O/O running a hopper? By a good living I mean $100,000 a year take home, because most full-time truck drivers can make that kind of money without the headache of owning a truck. If you run 20 hoppers you are making money on volume. "

Yes easily!

Replied on Mon, Aug 28, 2023 at 02:31 PM CST
+ 1
Quote: "I disagree. I have known things to move only because freight was cheap. And I have hauled useless stuff and made good money but the trader lost money. But it had to move."

Commodities (human consumables/feed, etc) are booked to production contract at the beginning of the season once seed has been bought or crop has been planted. Spot contracts get sold through out the growing season. the freight rates are set into the contract at that time. if the buyer has issues moving the contract (receiving space, etc.) then they would be under the wire to move it or lose it, worse yet pay a penalty if the producer has to sell it back to the market at a lower price. but i am sure all of you know this being in the industry.

Replied on Tue, Aug 29, 2023 at 07:05 AM CST
+ 1

So the guy from Farmersville still has not said which board he screen shot the loads from.....Also Good ole Uncle Paul told me that the hog farmers that stay in it year round year after year will make more money than the guy that jumps in and out with the market price.... same with trucking I think...I have a hopper and nice dry van I give service and I communicate with my broker , in out times ect. Also I run eld and have tracking they can see... oh also I am honest I also treat people with respect I think this might help me do better...

Replied on Tue, Aug 29, 2023 at 07:05 AM CST

Those rates look good brother, what load board is this?

Replied on Fri, Sep 01, 2023 at 08:24 PM CST
Quote: "So the guy from Farmersville still has not said which board he screen shot the loads from.....Also Good ole Uncle Paul told me that the hog farmers that stay in it year round year after year will make more money than the guy that jumps in and out with the market price.... same with trucking I think...I have a hopper and nice dry van I give service and I communicate with my broker , in out times ect. Also I run eld and have tracking they can see... oh also I am honest I also treat people with respect I think this might help me do better..."

I'm terribly sorry I don't live in the forums. My father passed away. So I've been a little busy. It's the DAT board. Apparently research isn't your forte
Replied on Mon, Sep 04, 2023 at 07:58 AM CST

Sorry to hear about your father passing. Mine past recently also, I do not have the dat board.